A moment of freedom

Like a reality TV star who can’t remember applying to take part in the show, ordinary, respectable Greek people have had all their dirty laundry aired in public over the past couple of years. It’s unlikely that the citizens of any other nation on earth have undergone such intense scrutiny as the Greeks. Everybody knows what the Greeks earn, what they pay in taxes, how they live, how much their wages have been reduced, how many hours they work, how much vacation time they have, what they spend their money on, how they vote and what their most personal fears are.

Much of this is to be expected as a result if the mess that Greece got itself into and the unprecedented loan packages that it has received. But the line must be drawn somewhere. These loans come with extreme conditionality. Just as Greeks’ personal lives are pored over, so the bailouts dictate not just economic policy but a whole range of other policies down to the finest details. This is the quid pro quo of the loan deals: Greece receives money in return for certain fiscal measures and structural reforms. Nowhere does the agreement dictate how people should vote in a free election.

This hasn’t prevented a number of European officials from expressing an opinion about their preferred outcome of Sunday’s vote. The latest to do so was Luxembourg Prime Minister Jean-Claude Juncker. «If the radical left wins – which cannot be ruled out – the consequences for the currency union are unforeseeable,» said Juncker, who as head of the Eurogroup also holds an institutional role within the European Union, a role that – theoretically – implies neutrality on such sensitive issues as national elections.

Juncker’s comment is in keeping with repeated interventions by Europeans over the last month. Their comments implied a deep disapproval of potential choices by free citizens. This began in February when German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble made the incredible suggestion that Greece should hold off elections and allow the interim government led by Lucas Papademos to stay in power for longer. This revealed a Europe that has become scared of democracy, unable to deal with the uncomfortable realities that it can produce.

How different things could have been if at that point Schaeuble and other European leaders could have made it clear that they would work with whatever government the Greeks elect as long as it is committed to remaining in the euro, as almost all the parties are. How refreshing that would have been for the European Union’s democratic principles. How it would have defused a tense situation and negated attempts by Greek politicians to stir up antagonism with Germany and the eurozone.

The opportunity was missed on both sides and Greeks head to the polls with this terrible chatter ringing in their ears. After living in the public eye for the last couple of years, the least they deserved was a moment of peace, a moment of freedom.

Nick Malkoutzis

10 responses to “A moment of freedom

  1. The facts dont support this tale. The fact is that the Greeks lied repeatedly about what they had borrowed. It took many rounds of investigations to uncover the massive frauds and rorts endemic across all layers of the Greeks, not just Govt and big business, but ordinary people, small businesses, the church, the whole lot of them. How soon we forget the facts.

  2. Pingback: Greek elections: Greece returns to the polls – live coverage

  3. My wife and I will take a vote to decide to cancel all our debts to third parties. We were unhappy at the adverse comment so we also agreed
    to vote that the earth is flat.

  4. “This revealed a Europe that has become scared of democracy, unable to deal with the uncomfortable realities that it can produce.”

    When those ‘uncomfortable’ realities are Greece defaulting on your nations debts potentially causing unprecedented losses in the financial sectors of Europe and wider, then I’d say it is wholly understandable that there may be a ‘fear of democracy’.

    Dating back to 1930’s Germany there have been politicians of European bodies and other nations offering their opinion in an attempt to influence which way nationals vote on sensitive issues such as this – sometimes they listen, sometimes they don’t….

  5. Why would anyone want to remain in a system that is run by the New York Stock Exchange? When they make ETF’s that control a whole country’s economy with the flick of a rich man’s switch, not to mention every other physical market (From pork bellies to cotton to oil), people will surely realize the truth.

  6. Metonmy – using the word “Greeks” to mean all Greeks. “Personification” – implying the the entity ‘Greece’ is a person, acting like, and with the moral responsibilities, of an individual. Pleeeese! It’s more complicated than…(Dad, dad, stop commenting on blog posts, only idiots even bother)

  7. The simple truth is Greece had been fiddling its national accounts for decades, that together with widespread tax evasion and government corruption its little wonder now Greece is facing a major euro sh*t storm. If the extreme left wins the elections, I think Greece will be forced to leave the euro ASAP.

  8. The part that counts is the # of seats, not so much the % vote:

    http://www.skai.gr/ekloges2012

  9. Pingback: What is PolicyMic? | Hot News and Topics,Celebrity Gossip News

  10. As a Brit, I would like to express my sympathy to Greek people at the way your country is being scapegoated. It amazes me how quickly history is being rewritten. Was it not only a few years ago we learned how international banks created a lot of this crisis with greedy reckless lending?
    We should be pulling together to help each other-it is too late for blame.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s